The early modern history of the Joseon dynasty (1392–1910) in East Asia is often depicted as an era of political conflict between the king, the Hun’gu faction, and the Sarim faction. The four major Sahwa (literati purges) reflect its seriousness through which Neo-Confucian scholars were sacrificed by the punishments of execution, exile, or dismissal. The Kimyo Sahwa was the most notorious incident for the Chinese ideology of the Sarim political party. What, then, happened in 1519? What kind of social transformation occurred in relation to the Sungkyunkwan scholars (the national university of the era)? Why did the public office of Daoist Sogyŏksŏ become one of the most controversial issues at the Joseon court? How was the royal shrine of Samch’ŏngjŏn criticised by the leaders of the Sarim faction? This paper explores the politico-religious landscape of early modern Korea through the key features of Jungjong coup (Royal Coup of 1506), Jo Gwangjo (1482–1520) and ‘the Literati Purge of 1519’, and argues the critical insight that the Daoist rituals and sacred sites (altars for the sky, stars, and gods) were traditionally maintained in the Pŏpcho philosophy of the royal sovereignty even if the culture of Jongmyo (ancestral altars) and Sajik (altars of soil and grain) were legally implemented at the beginning of the Confucian Joseon.
Ahn, Dong-gyo (2018) “Kyuam songinsuŭi hangmun’gwa ŭirijŏngshinŭi kuhyŏn”. [Gyuam Song In-su’s learning and realization of his fidelity spirit.] Yuhakyŏn’gu 45, 15–25.
https://doi.org/10.18216/yuhak.2018.45..001
Ahn, Dong-Zoon (2004) “Pukpanggye shinhwaŭi shin’gyŏng yuraewa togyoshinang”. [Daoist belief and origin divinity in the Northern Kingdoms.] Togyomunhwayŏn’gu 21, 11–14.
Byun, Kyu-yong (1986) “Taoism and Daoists”. Korea Journal 26, 5, 4–12.
Ch’a, Chu-hwan (1986) “Kim Shi-sup and Taoism”. Korea Journal 26, 5, 46–54.
Chae, Yun-mi (2019) “Kojŏnsosŏl song togyo hyŏngsanghwaŭi ilgoch’al -kwa ŭl chungshimŭro-”. [A study on the formation of Daoist images of Korean classical novels – in the cases of Imhwa Jongyon and Son Ch’onsa Yongirok.] Kojŏnmunhakkwa kyoyuk 40, 192–201.
Chang, Jae-cheon (2019) “Chosŏn chungjong huban’gi sŏnggyun’gwan yusaengdŭrŭi hakp’ung munje”. [In the Joseon Dynasty, the latter half of King Jungjong, Sungkyunkwan’s academic climate.] Han’guksasanggwa munhwa 97, 29–47.
https://doi.org/10.31037/KTAC.97.2
Cho, Woo-Jin (2020) “Hwasunyuhagŭi chŏn’gaewa nosahakp’aŭi hyŏngsŏng”. [The flow of Hwasun Confucianism and formation of Nohsa School.] Yongbonginmunnonch’ong 56: 289–304.
https://doi.org/10.35704/YJH.56.10
Chung, Doo Hee (1995) “Kimyosahwawa chogwangjo”. [The Literati Purge of 1519 and Cho Kwang-jo.] Yoksa Hakbo 146, 87–112.
Fisher, Carney T. (1988) “Smallpox, sales-men, and sectarians: Ming-Mongol relations in the Jiang-jing reign (1552–67)”. Ming Studies 25, 1–23.
https://doi.org/10.1179/014703788788760510
Henshall, Kenneth (2012) A history of Japan: from stone age to superpower. London: Palgrave Macmillan.
Hur, Joon (2020) “Chosŏn chungjongdae sogyŏksŏ kwallyŏn nonŭiŭi sangjingjŏng ŭimi”. [The symbolic meaning of the discussions about Sogyǒksǒ ritual in the reign of king Chungjong.] Sŏktangnonch’ong 78, 231–262.
Hwang, In Gyu (2015) “Han’gung chŏn’gŭndae togyoŭi suyonggwa tobult’ongsŏm -kŏsawa sŭngnyŏ kwallyŏn kirong kŏmt’orŭl chungshimŭro-”. [The adoption of Taoism and Daoist and Buddhist consilience in the period of pre-modern Korean society.] Han’guksasangsahak 50, 2–6.
Hwang, Man-ki (2017) “Maae kwŏnyeŭi samkwa nakkangjŏng”. [Maae Kwon Ye’s life and Nakgangjeong.] Yongnamhak 60, 179–206.
https://doi.org/10.36034/yncdoi.2017..60.179
“Irwŏrobongdo.” In Encyclopedia of Korean culture. Last modified January 1, 2021. Available online at
Jeong, Woo-lak (2005) “Sarimp’a muninŭi yuhyŏnggwa ŭn’guhyŏng(jyaeshwŏp’gya) sarimŭi chŏnjaengch’ehŏm -nammyŏnghakp’aŭi kyŏngurŭl chungshimŭro-”. [A study on the type of Sarim Literati and the war experience of rural member-focsing on the cases of Nammyung School.] Han’guksasanggwa munhwa 28, 7–62.
Jin, Sang-Won (2009) “Anch’ŏgyŏm oksawa chŏngch’ibŏm shinwŏn kwanhaengŭi chŏngch’ak”. [The event of an Cho Kyum and the formalization of the process for redressing grievances in the Chosun era.] Yŏksawa kyŏnggye 73, 36–42.
Ju, Sumi (s.a.) “Cheung pŏrigi”. [Deserting a straw effigy of exorcism.] In Pusanyŏksamunhwadaejŏn. Last modified December 20, 2020.
Kang, Jiyeon (2009) “Kwaŭi togyoŭi sŏngsoewa yuhakchaŭi kwan’gye -inŭnghwaŭi “chosŏndogyosa”rŭl chungshimŭro-”. [The relationship between rise and fall of Gwaui Daoism of Chosun and Confucian scholars: focusing on Yi Neunghwa’s.] Tongbanghak 16, 322–327.
Kim, Cheol-woong (2008) “Chosŏnjŏn’giŭi ch’amsŏngch’orye”. [A study on the Chamseong and Daoist ritual in the early Chosun period.] Togyomunhwayŏn’gu 28, 280–286.
Kim, Chng-ho (2016) “Ch’ogisarimp’a shie nat’anan segyesangŭi kyunyŏlgwa taeŭng -muo, kapchasahwagi yubaeshirŭl chungshimŭro-”. [The break of the world image and people’s response observed in the poems of the early Sarim faction.] Hanmunhangnonjip 43, 89–93.
https://doi.org/10.17260/jklc.2016.43..89
Kim, Deok Jin (2007) “Yangsanboŭi kimyosahwa ch’ehŏmgwa soswaewŏn kŏllip” [The Gimyosahwa’s Experienc and Sosaewon’s Build of Yang, San-Bo.] Yŏksahakyŏn’gu (ku chŏnnamsahak) 30: 83–118.
Kim, Jeong Shin (2020) “Chosŏnjŏn’gi sarim?sarimjŏngch’i yŏn’guŭi chaengjŏmgwa chŏnmang”. [The issue and prospects of research on the Sarim and Sarim politics of the early Joseon period.] Han’guksasangsahak 64 (April), 53–54.
https://doi.org/10.31309/SKHT.64.202004.2
Kim, Kyung-Soo (2018) “Chungjongdae yugyohwa ch’ujin’gwa ch’ungam kimjŏng”. [Confucianised and Chungam Kim Jeong in the reign of King Jungjong.] Yuhakyŏn’gu 44, 48–56.
https://doi.org/10.18216/yuhak.2018.44..002
Kim, Seong-Ryong (2012) “Sahoejŏng ŭisasot’ongŭrosŏŭi munhak”. [Literature as a social communication.] Munhakch’iryoyŏn’gu 25, 155–201.
Kim, Seong Hwan (2003) “Han’gung togwanŭi ch’ŏrhaksasangsajŏng yŏn’gu (2): chungsep’yŏn -kwanbangdogwanŭi sŏngnipkwa ch’ŏlp’ye-”. [A philosophical study on Korean Taoism.] Togyomunhwayŏn’gu 19, 29–72.
Kim, Tang Take (2015) “Chosŏn sŏngjongt’ch’ungjongdae chŏngch’isaŭi ihaewa “sarimp’a”sŏl” [Understanding political history of Songjong-Jungjong’s reign in Chosun Dynasty and Sarimp’a.] Yŏksahakyŏn’gu (ku chŏnnamsahak) 58, 1–31.
Kim, Yu Ri (2012) “Ch’ungam kimjŏngt’etchejup’ungt’orokt’erŭi kyoyukchŏng ŭimi” [The educational meaning of ‘Jeju Poong-To-Rock’ of (Choong Am) Kim Jung.] T’amnamunhwa 40, 225–249.
https://doi.org/10.35221/tamla.2012..40.007
Lee, Hae-jun (2013) “Shinbibogwiso ronnan’gwa chaep’yŏnggaŭi sŏnggyŏk”. [A study on the criticisms about the appeal for the restoration of Shin and the nature of its reevaluation.] Yuhakyŏn’gu 28, 37–62.
https://doi.org/10.18216/yuhak.2013.28..002
Lee, Jong-Eun (1986) “Taoism in Korean literature”. Korea Journal 26, 5, 32–34.
Lee, Jong Sung (2010) “Kŭndaewa mannan han’gugŭi togyo -inŭnghwa t’ekchosŏndogyosat’elmŭi kibonipchangŭl chungshimŭro-”. [Korean Taoism with modernism- based on Lee Neunghwa’s Daoistic history of Joseon.] Tongsŏch’ŏrhakyŏn’gu 58, 315–339.
Lee, Mi-seon (2017) “Chungjong hugung hŭibinhongssiŭi saengaewa haengbo- kimyosahwarŭl chungshimŭro-”. [On the life and Aactivities of Lady Hong Hi-bin, the Concubine of King Jung-jong in Joseon dynasty – focusing on the political incident Gimyosahwa in 1519.] Yŏsŏnggwa yŏksa 26, 171–197.
Lee, Neunghwa (2000) Chosŏndogyosa. [The Daoistic history of Joseon (1959).] Reprinted by Lee Jongeun, Seoul: Boseongmunhwasa.
Lee, Sang Seong (2010) “Chogwangjo tohagŭi inyŏmjŏng sunjŏngsŏnggwa kamsŏngŭi munje”. [Cho Gwang-jo’s pure conscience and grief.] Han’gukch’ŏrhangnonjip 30, 7–36.
https://doi.org/10.35504/kph.2010..30.001
Mun, Jae-yun (2009) “Chungjongdae “pŏpcho”ŭi chŏngch’iwŏlliwa chogwangjoŭi kyŏngjangnon”. [Political principle of ‘making a model of forefathers’ and Jo Kwang-jo’s reformation suggestion in Joongjong’s ruling period.] Youngnamhak 15, 345–347.
National Museum of Korea (s.a.) “Ch’ŏngja sanggam kuk’wamunŭi chŏpshi”. Last modified December 20, 2020. Available online at
<https://www.museum.go.kr/site/main/relic/directorysearch/view? elicId=4271>. Accessed on 04.10.2021.
Park, Chang Jin (1998) “Chosŏnjo kimyosarimŭi chŏngch’ijŏng wisange kwanhan yŏn’gu; chungjong 10nyŏn (1515) esŏ chungjong 14nyŏn (1519) kimyosahwaijŏnkkaji” [The political place of the Kimyo Literati in the Choson dynasty; from the tenth to the eve of the Kimyo literati purge (the fourteenth year) in Chungjong.] Han’gukchŏngch’ihak’oebo 32 2, 77–79.
Perez, Louis G (1998) The history of Japan. Westport, CT: Greenwood Press.
Seidel, Anna (1989) Chronicle of Daoist studies in the West 1950–1990. Loyang: Cahiers d’Extrême-Asie.
https://doi.org/10.3406/asie.1989.950
Son, Yoo Kyung (2009) “Mojae kiman’gugŭi shimunhang yŏn’gu -kŭŭi ch’ungjŏngshirŭl chungshimŭro-”. [Kim Ahn-Kook (Mo-Jae)’s perception of Japan.] Hanmun’gojŏnyŏn’gu 19, 31–53.
https://doi.org/10.18213/jkccl.2009.19.1.002
Song, Hang-nyong (1986) “A short history of Taoism in Korea”. Korea Journal 26, 5, 13–15.
Song, Woongsup (2001) “Chungjongdae kimyosarimŭi kusŏnggwa ch’ulshinbaegyŏng”. [The composition and original background of the Gimyo sarim at Junjong era.] Han’guksaron 45, 135–192.
Song, Woongsup (2005) “Kimyosahwawa kimyosarimŭi shilgak”. [Gimyo literati purge (1519) and political loose of the Gimyo sarim.] Hankuk Hakpo 31, 2, 70–120.
The Academy of Korean Studies (2020) Kimyomyŏnghyŏnŭi kkumgwa ujŏng, kŭrigo kiŏk. [The sages of the 1519 Purge: their ideals, friendship, and memory.] Seongnam: The Academy of Korean Studies Press.
Um, Ki-Young (2011) “Kijaegiit’elmwa chakcha shin’gwanghanŭi chagiinshing -kwa ŭl taesangŭro-”. [Kijaekiyi and the self-awareness of Shin, Kwanghan.] Kososŏryŏn’gu 32, 107–115.
Wagner, Edward Willett (1974) The Literati Purges: political conflict in early Yi Korea. Cambridge: East Asian Research Center, Harvard University Press.
https://doi.org/10.1163/9781684171897
Yang, Eunyong and Samyong Choe (1988) “Pogwŏn’gung sŏllibŭi yŏksajŏng ŭimi”. [The historical meaning of the establishment of Bogwongung.]” In Togyomunhwayŏn’gu [Studies in Daoistic culture] 2, 488–89. Seoul, Korean Association of Daoism Culture.
You, Byung-Rae (2006) “Chosŏnjo sogyŏkchŏnŭi yŏnwŏn’gwa t’ŏe kwanhan koch’al”. [A study on the origin of Joseon’s Sogyeokjeon and its site.] Han’guksasanggwa munhwa 32, 130–135.
You, Byung-Rae (2007) “Chosŏnjo samch’ŏngjŏn(dwŏlyŏtjur)ŭi kŏllim paegyŏnggwa t’ŏ[lp]ŭi wich’ie kwanhan koch’al”. [The study of the background of the Erection of Sam-Chung-Jeon and the position of its site during the Joseon dynasty.] Han’guksasanggwa munhwa 40, 232–235.
Yun, Chan Won (2003) “Chaech’omunŭi chŏltaeja kwannyŏmŭl t’onghae pon chosŏn ch’oŭi togyosasang”. [A religious Daoistic thoughts of early Cho-sun period mirrored in concepts of the absolute in Zhai-jiao.] Togyomunhwayŏn’gu 18, 56–82.
