In October 1944, Churchill presented to Stalin a proposal for division of spheres of influence in Eastern Europe, unaware that at the same time the Soviet Union annexed the Tuva People’s Republic. This state was reduced to a subordinate entity within the USSR. Declassified documents, released fifty years later, revealed that the Soviet leadership had coordinated its pre-World War II expansionist policies in both the Baltic-Black Sea region and in centre of Asia. Motivated by Churchill’s proposal, Stalin swiftly adjusted his geopolitical strategy in negotiations with Finland, adding territorial reconfigurations within the Soviet Union. Some territories of the Karelo-Finnish and Estonian SSR’s were rapidly transferred to the Leningrad oblast. Ironically, Molotov, one of the architects of the Molotov-Ribbentrop Pact, would later conclude his career by signing the agreement about transfer of Soviet territory (part of Tuva) to Mongolia, a gesture aimed at preserving Soviet-Chinese relations in 1958.
Alatalu, Toomas (1991a) “Tuva – Baltikumi saatusekaaslane”. [Tuva – a companion of fate for the Baltics.] Poliitika: teoreetiline ja poliitiline kuukiri (Tallinn) 11, 60–67.
Alatalu, T. (1991b) “Tuva – Pribaltika: istoričeskije paralleli”. [Tuva – the Baltics: historical parallels.] Poliitika: teoreetiline ja poliitiline kuukiri (Tallinn) 11, 44–54.
Alatalu, Toomas (1992a“Tuva – Pribaltika: istoričeskije paralleli”. [Tuva – the Baltics: historical parallels.] Molodëz’ Tuvy, 24 January. Kyzyl. RSFSR, 3, 2064.
Alatalu, Toomas (1992b) “Tuva – a state reawakens”. Soviet Studies (University of Glasgow) 44, 5, 881–895.
https://doi.org/10.1080/09668139208412051
Alatalu, Toomas (2000) “Not the events of 1940 in the Baltics, but the events of 1939–1944 in Finland, Estonia, Latvia, Lithuania, Slovakia and Tyva”. The Monthly Survey of Baltic and Post-Soviet Politics. (Eurouniversity Series. International relations, Tallinn. Eurouniversity) 2, 104, 101–107.
Alatalu, Toomas and Michael Strupp (2012) “Tuva”. In Rüdiger Wolfrum, ed. The Max Planck encyclopedia of public international law. Vol 10, 124–127. New York: Oxford University Press.
https://doi.org/10.1093/law:epil/9780199231690/e1939
Alatalu, Toomas (2013) “Geopolicy taking the signature from the Russian-Estonian Border Treaty (2005)”. Baltic Journal of European Studies 3, 2(14), 96–119.
https://doi.org/10.2478/bjes-2013-0015
Alatalu, Toomas (2024) “Geopoliitika Nõukogude Liidu 1944. a. vallutuste jadas. Petserimaa ja Abrene,, Petsamo ja Narva jõe tagune ala ning tänapäevani lõpetamata sõda.” Akadeemia 6 (423), pp. 1091–1120.
Ant, Jüri, Küllo Arjakas, Heino Arumäe, Tiit Arumäe, and Peeter Vares, eds. (1991) Baaside lepingust annektsioonini. Dokumente ja materjale. [From the Bases Agreement to annexation: documents and materials.] Tallinn: Kirjastus Perioodika.
“Armistice Agreement between the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics and the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland, on the one hand, and Finland on the other hand (1944)” heninen.net. Available online at
https://heninen.net/sopimus/1944_e.htm Accessed 5 May 2024.
Arumäe, Heino (1991) Mõnda Hans Kruusist, Mongoolia eeskujust ja poliitilisest naivismist. [Some thoughts on Hans Kruus, the Mongolian model, and political naivety.] Looming (Tallinn) 10, 1381–1390.
Badajev, Aleksei Jegorovits (2015) In A. O. Chubaryana, ed. Rossiiskaja istoričeskaja èntsiklopedia.Vol 2. Moscow: Abris/Olma. Available at
http://hrono.ru/biograf/bio_b/badaev_ae.php Accessed 5 May 2024.
Baiyr-ool, Mongush (2012) “1944 god. Kak opredeljalsja osobyj status respubliki v sostave RSFSR”. Tuvinskaja Pravda, 11th octobre. Available online at
http://www.tuvaonline.ru/2012/10/11/1944-god-kak-opredelyalsya-osobyy-status-respubliki-v-sostave-sssr.html Accessed on 14 April 2025.
Brilyov, Sergei (2013) Zabytye sojuzniki vo Vtoroj mirovoj vojne. Moscow: OLMA Media Group.
Churchill, Winston (1953) The Second World War. Vol. 6: Triumph and tragedy. Boston: Houghton Mifflin Company and Cambridge, Massachusetts: The Riverside Press.
Churchill, Winston (1971) The Second World War. Vol. 3. Grand Alliance. London: Cassell.
Davõdov, Ilya (2008) “Vladimir Uljanovi (Lenini) allkirjaga dokument 16. novembrist 1917 Narva Linnavalitsuse arhiivifondis”. [Document signed by Vladimir Ulyanov (Lenin) from November 16, 1917, in the Narva City Government Archive fund.] Tuna(Tallinn)1, 76–84. Available online at
www.ra.ee/wp-content/uploads/2016/10DavodovIlja_Vladimir_Uljanovi_TUNA2008_1.pdf Accessed on 14 April 2025.
“Dokumente Petseri- ja Virumaa jaotamise kohta. Vol 2”. [Documents on the division of Petseri and Virumaa. Vol 2.] (1991 Akadeemia(Tartu) 1991, 9, 1949–1963.
Gasanly, Dzamil (2003) Juznyj Azerbajdžan: načalo xolodnoj vojny. Baku: Adilogly.
“Gosudarstvennyj doklad ‘100-letie edinenija Tuvy i Rossii’”. Tuvinskaja Pravda, 10 September 2014. Available online at
http://www.tuvaonline.ru/2014/09/10/gosudarstvennyy-doklad-100-letie-edineniya-tuvy-i-rosiii.html Accessed on 5 May 2024.
Hansalu, Olev (2005) Carl Gustaf Mannerheim – Põhjala suurmees. [Carl Gustaf Mannerheim – The Great Man of the North.] Tallinn: Elmatar.
Kharunova, M. M.-B. (2009) “Tuva i SSSR: Process političeskoj integracii”. Tuva. Asia. Novye issledovanija Tuvy 3. Available online at
http://www.tuva.asia/journal/issue_3/467-harunova.html Accessed on 14 April 2025.
Kharunova, Marianna (2011) Social’no-politiceskoe razvitiye Tuvy v seredine XX veka. Novosibirsk: Nauka.
Khomushku, Yuliya (2002) Processy sbliženija i vhoždenija Tuvinskoj Narodnoj Respubliki v sostav CCCP: 20-40-e gody XX veka. Avtoreferat dissertacii kandidata istoričeskix nauk. Moscow.
Köörna, Arno, Jaan Lepp, Heiki Lindpere, Lennart Meri, and Eerik Truuväli, eds. (1990). 1940. aasta Eestis. Dokumente ja materjale.[Estonia in 1940: documents and materials.] Tallinn: Olion.
Lopukhovskij, L. N. and B. Kavalerčhik (2010) Ijun’ 1941 goda. Zaprogrammirovanoe porazenie. Moskva, Jauza, Eksmo, 2010”. Sajt “Militera” (“Voennaja literatura”) Available online at
https://militera.org/research/all/l/b39438/ Accessed 14 April 2025.
Mansvetov, Fedor (1947) “Tannu-Tuva – the Soviet ‘Atom-City’”. The Russian Review 6, 2, 9–19.
https://doi.org/10.2307/125304
“Materialy o vxozdenii Tuvy v 1944 godu v SSSR. Doklad Predsedatelya VS RT K.A.Bicheldeja na XIV vneocerednoi sessii VS RT”. (1992). Sodejstvie (Kyzyl), 11–12 March 1992.
Mattisen, Edgar (1996) Searching for a dignified compromise. The Estonian-Russian border 1000 years. Tallinn: Ilo.
Mollerov, Nikolai (2004) “Istoričeskyi kazus. TNR protiv gitlerovskoj Germanii: 63 goda voobrazaemoj voiny”. Tuvinskaja Pravda (Kyzyl), 30 December, 164, 15975.
Moskalenko, Nelli (2004) Etnopolitičeskaja istorija Tuvy v XX veke. Moskva: Nauka.
“Na XIII sjezde Mongolskoj narodno-revolucionnoj partii. (1958). Recj tovarištša N. G. Ignatova”. Pravda Moscow), 20. March 1958, 79, 14473.
Noormets, Tiit (2001). eestlaste ja teiste rahvusvähemuste ümberasustamine Loode-Venemaalt Saksa okupatsiooni ajal 1942–1943. Tuna (journal, Tallinn), N 2, pp. 39–55.
Otvety (Prezidenta Putina) na voprosy zhurnalista Pavla Zarubina 24 fevralya 2025 goda (2025).
www.kremlin.ru/events/president/news/76331
Otroshchenko, Ivanna (2017) “Vhozdenije Tuvy v sostav SSSR: alternativnye mnenija”. Tuva. Asia. Novye issledovanija Tuvy 4, 36–76.
https://www.doi.org/10.25178/nit.2017.4.3
Otroshchenko, Ivanna (2019) “Tuvinskaja Narodnaja Respublika nakanune vxozdenija v sostav SSSR glazami sovetskovo diplomata”. Tuva. Asia. Novye issledovanija Tuvy. 4, 207–215.
https://doi.org/10.25178/nit.2019.4.17
Oyun, Dina (2010) “Tuvinskaja Narodnaja Respublika operedila Velikobritaniju v ob’’javlenii voiny fašistkoi Germanii”. Tuvaonline.ru, 5 March 2010. Available online at
https://www.tuvaonline.ru/2010/05/05/print:page,1,4212_pobeda.html Accessed on 14 March 2025.
Oyun, Dina (2012) “68 let nazad Tuva vošla v sostav Rossii”. Tuvaonline.ru, 11 Octobre 2012. Available online at
http://www.tuvaonline.ru/2012/10/11/68-let-nazad-tuva-voshla-v-sostav-rossii.html Accessed on 14 March 2025.
“Percentages agreement”. Wikipedia.Available online at
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Percentages_agreement Accessed on 14 March 2025.
Reynolds, David and Vladimir Pechatnov, eds. (2018) The Kremlin letters: Stalin’s wartime corres-pondence with Churchill and Roosevelt. New Haven and London: Yale University Press.
https://doi.org/10.12987/9780300241044
Rupen, Robert (1977) “The absorption of Tuva”. In Thomas T. Hammond, ed. The anatomy of Communist takeovers, 151-152. New Haven, Conn.: Yale University Press.
Rupnik, Jacques (1989) The other Europe. Pantheon Books, New York.
Sanders, Alan (2017) Historical dictionary of Mongolia. 4th ed. (Historical Dictionaries of Asia, Oceania, and the Middle East.) Lanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield Publishers.
Sbornik zakonov RSFSR i ukazov Prezidiuma Verxovnogo Soveta RSFSR. 1938–1946 gg. Moskva: Izdatels’tvo Izvestija Sovetov deputatov trudjaštšijsja SSSR, 1946.
Sbornik zakonov SSSR i ukazov Prezidiuma Verxovnogo Soveta SSSR. 1938–1975: (v cetyrex tomax). Vol. 1. Moskva. Izdatels’tvo Izvestija Sovetov deputatov trudjaštšijsja SSSR 1975.
“Solgašenije meždu pravitel’stvom Respubliki Tuva i Pravitel’stvom Dalai-lamy o kulturnom i religioznom sotrudnichestve na period 1993–1995 gg.”. Tuvinskaja Pravda (Kyzyl), 24 September 1992, 2.
Sonam, Soyan (1992) “Tuva-Mongolija: pograničnij process”. Molodjož Tuvy, 10 April 1992, 10.
Tannberg, Tõnu (2011) Miks Hans Kruusist ei saanud Eesti NSV välisasjade rahvakomissar juba 1944. aasta kevadel? [Why didn’t Hans Kruus become the People’s Commissar for Foreign Affairs of the Estonian SSR already in the spring of 1944?] Tuna (Tallinn) 3, 72–87.
Tannu-Tuva (U.R.S.S.) (1946) HC Deb 1 December 1946 vol 431c1148.
“TANNU TUVA (U.S.S.R.) HC Deb 11 December 1946 vol 431 c1148”. Available at
https://api.parliament.uk/historic-hansard/commons/1946/dec/11/tannu-tuva-ussr Accessed on 14 April 2025.
Tazhutov, Akhas (2022) “Why should Russia ‘The Last Living White Nation’ have Sergei Shoigu (a Tuvan) as its top general in Ukrainian War?”. EurasiaReview. News and Analysis, 4 November Available online at
https://www.eurasiareview.com/04112022-why-should-russia-the-last-living-white-nation-have-sergei-shoigu-a-tuvan-as-its-top-general-in-ukrainian-war-analysis/ Accessed on 14 April 2025.
“Territorial’nye pretenzii Mongolii k Tuve: kak eto bylo v 1957 godu”. Molodjož Tuvy, 27 December 1991, 33.
Tsitskin, Aleksei (2017). Neizvestnye sojuzniki Stalina: 1940–1945 gg. (Voenno-istoričeskaja biblioteka.) Izdatel’stvo Veče.
Vares, Peeter and Olga Osipova (1992) Poxišenije Evropy ili Baltiiski vopros v meždunardonyx otnošenijax XX veka. Tallinn: Izdatelstvo Éstonskoi entsiklopedii.
Wolff, David (2011) “Stalin’s postwar border-making tactics. East and West”. Cahiers du Monde Russe 52, 2–3.
http://doi.org/10.4000/monderusse.9334
Zubkova, Yelena (2008). Pribaltika i Kreml 1940–1953. Moscow: POSSPEN.
