Wilhelm Dilthey on the Objectivity of Knowledge in Human Sciences

(full text in pdf format)

Andrus Tool

University of Tartu

Abstract. Wilhelm Dilthey was one of the first thinkers whose philosophy centred on the reflection of the nature of human sciences. These sciences had evolved into academic disciplines already within the context of the concept of scientificalness (Wissenschaftlichkeit) of German Idealism. They underwent a certain crisis of foundations in the nineteenth century in connection with the general rise of empiricism in the conception of science as such. Dilthey’s goal was to provide these sciences with philosophical-epistemological foundation as a specific domain of empirical research sciences. One of the aspects of his philosophical analyses along these lines was the grounding of the objectivity of the research results of the given sciences. The very success of human sciences in their inherent aspiration to exert counter influence on social life depended directly, as he saw it, on attaining this particular goal. Two focuses can be distinguished in Dilthey’s treatment of objectivity. On the one hand, he strives to demonstrate how justified is the pretension of the representations of human sciences to attain the genuine social-historical reality. On the other hand, he tries to prove that the particular representations of human sciences are justified in their pretensions to universal validity. Dilthey’s analyses face major difficulties in the process of attaining both these goals, which forces him to modify his understanding of the role of human sciences in human life.

Keywords: Wilhelm Dilthey, human sciences, objectivity, lived experience, social life, understanding, liberty

References

1. De Mul, Jos (2004) The Tragedy of Finitude. Dilthey`s Hermeneutics of Life. New Haven & London: Yale University Press.

2. Dilthey, Wilhelm (1989) Selected works. Volume I: Introduction to the human sciences. Princeton: Princeton University Press.

3. Dilthey, Wilhelm (2002a) “The Delimitation of the Human Sciences”. In Selected Works. Vol. 3, pp. 91–97. Wilhelm Dilthey, ed. Princeton: Princeton University Press.

4. Dilthey, Wilhelm (2002b) “The Formation of the Historical World in the Human Sciences”. In Selected Works. Vol. 3, pp. 101–209. Wilhelm Dilthey, ed. Princeton: Princeton University Press.

5. Dilthey, Wilhelm (2002c) “Plan for the Continuation of the Formation of the Historical World in Human Sciences”. In Selected Works. Vol. 3, pp. 213–311. Wilhelm Dilthey, ed. Princeton: Princeton University Press.

6. Dilthey, Wilhelm (1974a) “Beiträge zur Lösung der Frage vom Ursprung unseres Glaubens an Realität der Aussenwelt und seinem Recht”. In Gesammelte Schriften. Bd. 5, 6. Aufl. Wilhelm Dilthey, ed. Göttingen: Vandenhoeck&Ruprecht, S. 90–138.

7. Dilthey, Wilhelm (1974b) “Die Entstehung der Hermeneutik” In Gesammelte Schriften. Bd. 5, 6. Aufl. Wilhelm Dilthey, ed. Göttingen: Vandenhoeck&Ruprecht, S. 317–338.

8. Ineichen, Hans (1975) Erkenntnistheorie und geschichtlich-gesellschaftliche Welt. Diltheys Logik der Geisteswissenschaften. Frankfurt am Main: Vittorio Klostermann.

9. Ineichen, Hans (1991) Philosophische Hermeneutik. Freiburg/München: Karl Alber Verlag.

10. Lessing, Hans-Ulrich (1984) Die Idee einer Kritik der historischen Vernunft. Wilhelm Diltheys erkenntnistheoretisch-logisch-metodologische Grundlegung der Geisteswissenschaften. Freiburg/München: Karl Alber Verlag.

11. Makkreel, Rudolf (1992) Dilthey: Philosopher of the Human Studies. Princeton

12. Römelt, Johannes (1999) Die Kant-Kritik Wilhelm Diltheys und das Problem der Legitimierung von Erfahrungserkenntnis. Kevelaer: Butzon und Bercker.

13. Schnädelbach, Herbert (1991) Philosophie in Deutschland 1831–1933. 4. Aufl. Frankfurt am Main: Suhrkamp.