eesti teaduste
akadeemia kirjastus
SINCE 1984
Oil Shale cover
Oil Shale
ISSN 1736-7492 (Electronic)
ISSN 0208-189X (Print)
Impact Factor (2020): 0.934

Assessment of the economic regulation of network industries: oil shale value chain in Estonia; pp. 158–176

Full article in PDF format |

Raigo Uukkivi, Ott Koppel


Naturally monopolistic network industries are subject to economic regulation to achieve an optimal use of infrastructure and avoid the abuse of monopolistic power. In theory, such intervention leads to a higher allocative and productive efficiency in the industry. Relatively little is known about the results the economic regulation gives in practice and whether it achieves the objectives set. Literature states that due to the context-specific nature of regulatory framework, ex post analysis and practical experiments are necessary to be performed to study the impact of economic regulation on the performance of industries. In this paper, analysis of the impact of economic regulation on the oil shale value chain in Estonia is performed and the results are provided. Based on relevant policy documents, regulatory objectives and targets are identified and indicators compiled to monitor the results. The discussion is presented and recommendations for further research are given.



 1. Jacobs, S. Regulatory impact assessment and the economic transition to markets. Public Money Manag., 2004, 24(5), 283‒290.

2. Radaelli, C. M. Regulatory indicators in the European Union and the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development: Performance assessment, organizational processes, and learning. Public Policy Adm., 2018, 1‒26.

3. Eerma, D. Possibilities of Economic Policy for Regulation of Sector-Specific Markets in Small Country: the Case of Baltic Countries. LAP LAMBERT Academic Publishing, Saarbrücken, Germany, 2013.

4. Uukkivi, R., Ots, M., Koppel, O. Systematic approach to economic regulation of network industries in Estonia. Trames: Journal of the Humanities and Social Sciences, 2014, 18(3), 221‒241.

5. Ots, M. Practical Implementation of Price Regulation in Energy Sector. PhD Thesis. Tallinn University of Technology, TUT Press, 2016.

6. Uukkivi, R., Koppel, O. Economic regulation assessment of network industries: railway infrastructure management in Estonia. Estonian Discussions on Economic Policy, 2018, 26(1–2), 155−171.

7. Kearns, J. Trends in Estonian Oil Shale Utilization. International Centre for Defence and Security, Tallinn, Estonia. 2015, 1‒22.

8. Kallemets, K. Economic sustainability of Estonian shale oil industry until 2030. Oil Shale, 2016, 33(3), 272‒289.

9. National Audit Office of Estonia. State Action in Direction of Oil Shale Utilization. Tallinn, 2014 (in Estonian).

10. Ministry of the Environment of Estonia. Progress Report on the Implementation of the National Development Plan for the Use of Oil Shale 2016–2030 for the years 2016 and 2017. Tallinn, 2019 (in Estonian).

11. Porter, M. E. Competitive Advantage: Creating and Sustaining Superior Performance. Simon and Schuster, 2008.

12. Ruigrok, W., Tulder, R. van The Logic of International Restructuring. Routledge, 1995.

13. Williamson, O. E. The economics of organization: The transaction cost approach. American J. Sociol., 1981, 87(3), 548‒577.

14. Batlle, C., Ocana, C. Electricity regulation: principles and institutions. In: Regulation of the Power Sector (Perez-Arriaga, I. J., ed.). Springer-Verlag, London. 2013, 125‒150.

15. Gomez, T. Monopoly regulation. In: Regulation of the Power Sector (Perez-Arriaga, I. J., ed.). Springer-Verlag, London. 2013, 151‒198.

16. Baumol, W. J. On the proper cost test for natural monopoly in a multiproduct industry. Am. Econ. Rev., 1977, 67(1), 809–822.

17. Baumol, W. J., Bailey, E. E., Willig, R. D. Weak invisible hand theorems on the sustainability of multiproduct natural monopoly. Am. Econ. Rev., 1977, 67(3), 350–365.

18. Joskow, P. L. Regulation of Natural Monopolies. Center for Energy and Environmental Policy Research, Working Paper 05-008, 2005, 1‒186.

19. Cogman, D. Allocation of Access Rights to Rail Network Infrastructure. Research Paper (Graduate School of Business, Stanford University) 1690, 2001, 1–48.

20. Hertog, J. den. Review of Economic Theories of Regulation. Discussion Paper Series nr: 10-18, Utrecht School of Economics, 2010, 1‒59.

21. Knieps, G. The Three Criteria Test, the Essential Facilities Doctrine and the Theory of Monopolistic Bottlenecks. Discussion Papers 132, University of Freiburg, Institute for Transport Economics and Regional Policy, 2010, 1‒13.

22. Knieps, G. Competition and Third Party Access in Railroads. Discussion Papers 150, University of Freiburg, Institute for Transport Economics and Regional Policy, 2014, 1‒21.

23. Radaelli, C. M., De Francesco, F. Regulatory Quality in Europe: Concepts, Measures, and Policy Processes. European Policy Studies, Manchester University Press, Manchester, 2007.

24. Coglianese, C. Measuring Regulatory Performance: Evaluating the Impact of Regulation and Regulatory Policy. OECD Expert Paper No. 1, OECD Publishing, Paris. 2012, 1‒59.

25. Arndt, C., Baker, A. C., Querbach, T., Schultz, R. Indicators of Regulatory Policy and Governance: Design, Methodology and Key Results. OECD Regulatory Policy Working Papers, No. 1, OECD Publishing, Paris. 2015, 1‒65.

26. Estonian Environmental Research Centre. Data on Energy Production Balance and Oil Shale Utilisation in Estonia 2017‒2018. Correspondence with the authors 09.07.2019.

27. Brendow, K. Global oil shale issues and perspectives. Synthesis of the symposium on oil shale held in Tallinn (Estonia) on 18 and 19 November 2002. Oil Shale, 2003, 20(1), 81‒92. 

28. Ernst & Young Baltic. Estonian Oil Shale Mining and Oil Production: Macroeconomic Impacts Study, 2014, 1‒63.

29. The Earth’s Crust Act, RT I, 12.12.2018, 53.

30. Estonian Land Board. Annual balances of mineral deposits 2008‒2018 (in Estonian).

31. Ministry of the Environment of Estonia. Data on the Utilisation of Oil Shale in Estonia 2007‒2017. Correspondence with the authors 02.01.2019.

32. CO2 European Emission Allowances Price Commodity.

33. Directive 2003/87/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council. OJ L 275, 25.10.2003.


34. Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communications of Estonia. National Development Plan of the Energy Sector until 2030. Tallinn, 2017, 1124.

35. Ministry of the Environment of Estonia. National Development Plan for the Utilization of Oil Shale 2008‒2015. Tallinn, 2008, 151.

36. Ministry of the Environment of Estonia. National Development Plan for the Use of Oil Shale 2016‒2030. Tallinn, 2016, 175.

37. Estonian Environmental Board. Selected environmental data on oil shale industry 2008‒2018. Correspondence with the authors 25.06.2019.

38. Ministry of the Environment of Estonia. Data on resource tariffs and environmental charges paid by oil shale industries 2008‒2018. Correspondence with the authors 26.03.2019.

39. Kuhi, K., Kõrbe, K., Koppel, O. A concept for performance measurement and evaluation in network industries. P. Est. Acad. Sci., 2015, 64(4S), 536‒542.

Back to Issue