headerpos: 9509
 
 
  Trames
A Journal of the Humanities and Social Sciences

ISSN 1736-7514 (electronic)  ISSN 1406-0922 (print)
Published since 1997

Trames
A Journal of the Humanities and Social Sciences

ISSN 1736-7514 (electronic)  ISSN 1406-0922 (print)
Published since 1997

Publisher
Information
» Policy statement
» Editorial board
» Editorial programme
Article Publication Charges
Style sheet
Subscription Information
Support and Contact
List of Issues
» 2018
» 2017
» 2016
Vol. 20, Issue 4
Vol. 20, Issue 3
Vol. 20, Issue 2
Vol. 20, Issue 1
» 2015
» 2014
» 2013
» 2012
» 2011
» 2010
» 2009
» 2008
» Back Issues
» Back issues (full texts)
  in Google
Publisher
» Other journals
» Staff

EMIL KRAEPELIN’S SUCCESSOR PROF. VLADIMIR CHIZH, HIS RESEARCH METHODS AND –OBJECTS; pp. 417–430

(Full article in PDF format) DOI: 10.3176/tr.2016.4.07


Authors

Ken Kalling

Abstract

Professor of psychiatry Vladimir Chizh was a successor of Emil Kraepelin at the University of Tartu (now: Estonia; then: Russian Empire) during the years 1891–1916. The same period witnessed the second and decisive rise in Estonian national movement leading finally to the foundation of Estonian state in 1918. A particular character in Estonian national discourse was its notorious biologisation, i.e. strong presence of eugenical ideology. Professor Chizh’s scientific research supported this tendency. In 1901 Chizh published a study in which he compared the criminal activity of Estonians and Latvians. Chizh’s method derived from an assumption that the two neighbouring Baltic populations possess an extremely similar environmental, cultural and socio-political background. The biological (racial) essence of the two groups he believed to differ – Latvians belonging to Indo-European nations, Estonians being Finnic. Deriving from the previous – if any differences in the criminal behaviour of the two existed, these could be explained by biological factors. In the results of his work Chizh reported on a notorius disbalance in the criminality of the two nations, Estonians exceeding Latvians in a rough ratio 5:3. Chizh, supporting the teaching of Cesare Lombroso, had achieved in such a way his goal, i.e. he believed that he had proved the biological essence of criminal behaviour. For the Estonian community the study by Chizh opened a subsequent field for further discussions on the topic ‘nature versus nurture’.

Keywords

Vladimir Chizh, Juhan Luiga, criminal antropology, race studies, eugenics.

References

Aadamsoo , Arno (1973) “V. F. Tšiž ja omaaegne Tartu ülikooli närvi- ja vaimuhaiguste kliinik”. [V. F. Chizh and the once Clinic of Neurology and Psychiatry at the University of Tartu.] Nõukogude Eesti Tervishoid 4 , 348–350.

Aro , Tuija (1985) “Suomalaisten rotu saksalaisissa ja pohjoismaisissa tietosanakirjoissa” [The Finnish race in German and Scandinavian encyclopaedias]. Mongoleja vai germaaneja? , 195–208. Helsinki: SKS.

Chizh , Vladimir (2016) Kirjanik psühhiaatri silmis. [A Writer as Seen by a Psychiatrist) Tartu: Ilmamaa.

Chizh , Vladimir (1901) “Vlijanie natsional’nosti na prestupnost’”. [On the effects of nationality on criminality.] Vestnik Prava 9 , 41–59.

Chizh , Vladimir (1902) Učebnik psixiatrii. [Psychiatry textbook.] Jur’jev: K. Mattisen.

Chizh , Vladimir (1906) “Nasledstvennost’ talanta u našix izvestnyx dejatelei”. [Inheritance of giftedness among our famous persons.] Sitzungsberichte der Naturforscher Gesellschaft bei der Universität Jurjev XV , 2 , 67–72.

Chizh , Vladimir (1908) “Značenie političeskoj žizni v etiologii duševnyx boleznei”. [Effect of political life to the ethiology of mental disease.] Obozrenie psixiatrii , nevrologii i eksperi­mental’noi psixologii 1 , 1–12; 2 , 149–162.

Grau , Karl (1911) “Vargustest meie kodumaal ja nende vastu võitlemise abinõudest”. [About the crime of theft in our homeland and the possibilities to fight it.] Sakala 88 , 6.

Hellat , Peeter (1910) Surma hirm ja tema seltskondline mõju. [Fear of death and its impact on public.] Peterburi: Ühiselu.

Kalling , Ken (2013) “Application of Eugenics in Estonia 1918–1940”. In Björn Felder , and Paul Weindling , eds. Baltic eugenics: bio-politics , race and nation in interwar Estonia , Latvia and Lithuania , 49–82. Amsterdam: Rodopi.

Kalling , Ken and Leiu Heapost (2013) “Racial identity and physical anthropology in Estonia 1800–1945”. In Björn Felder , and Paul Weindling , eds. Baltic eugenics: bio-politics , race and nation in interwar Estonia , Latvia and Lithuania , 83–114. Amsterdam: Rodopi.

Koppel , Henrik (1902) “Eestlased”. [Estonians.] Postimees 22 , 1.

Klossovsky , Alexander (1905) “Sravnitel’naja prestupnost’ sredi estov i latyšei Lifl’andskoj gubernii (etnografičeskaja zametka)”. [Comparison of criminality between Estonians and Latvians in the Livonian Province (etnographic note).] Zapiski Novorossiiskago obšestva estestvoispyta­telei 27 , 75–78.

Landau , Eber (1912) Kratkoe rukovodstvo k izučeniju antropologij. [A short directory into the studies of anthropology.] Jur’jev: K. Mattisen.

Lederer , David (2013) “Sociology’s “One Law”: moral statistics , modernity , religion , and German nationalism in the suicide studies of Adolf Wagner and Alexander von Oettingen”. Journal of Social History 46 , 3 , 684–699. doi:10.1093/jsh

Lees , Andrew (2002) Cities , sin , and social reform in imperial Germany. Ann Arbor: The University of Michigan Press.
https://doi.org/10.3998/mpub.17101

Lellep , Konstantin (1927a) “Der Einfluss der Rasse auf die Kriminalität der Esten”. Monatsschrift für Kriminalpsychologie und Strafrechtsreform 18 , 3 , 145–149.

Lellep , Konstantin (1927b) “Kuritegevus Eestis”. [Criminal activities in Estonia.] Eesti Arst 1 , 14–20.

Luiga , Juhan (1904) Prizrenie duševnobolnyx v pribaltiiskom kra’e. Istoriko-statističeskii očerk. Jur’jev: Tipografija gaz. “Postimees”.

Luiga , Juhan (1909a) “Cesare Lombroso †”. Päevaleht 232 , 1.

Luiga , Juhan (1909b) “Mäss ja meelehaigus”. [Mutiny and mental disease.] Päevaleht 226 , 1; 232 , 5.

Mark , Karin , Leiu Heapost , and Galina Sarap (1994) Eestlaste antropoloogia seoses etnogeneesi küsimustega. Tallinn: Teaduste Akadeemia Kirjastus.

Nelis , Mari , Reedik Mägi , Fritz Zimprich , Alexander Zimprich , et al. (2009) “Genetic structure of Europeans: a view from the North-East”. PLoS ONE 4 (5) Cited from: http:// journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0005472
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0005472

Pirogov , Nikolai (1885) Voprosy žizni. Dnevnik starogo vrača. [Issues of life. Memoirs of an old doctor.] S.-Peterburg: V. Balashov.

Pung , Mihkel (1902) “Kuritööd eestlaste ja lätlaste juures”. [Crimes among Estonians and Latvians.] Teataja 40–43 , 1.

Ramul , Konstantin (1974) “Psühholoogia Tartu Ülikoolis (1802–1918)”. [Psychiatry at the University of Tartu in 1802–1918.] From the history of psychology. Из истории психо­логии. Tartu: Tartu Riiklik Ülikool.

Raun , Toivo (2005) “1905. aasta revolutsioon Balti provintsides ja Soomes”. [The 1905 Revolution in the Baltic Provinces and Finland.] Tuna 1 , 32–43.

Sirotkina , Irina (2002) Diagnosing literary genius: a cultural history of psychiatry in Russia , 1880-1930. Baltimore and London: The John Hopkins University Press. Cited from: https:// www.scribd.com/document/249696412/Irina-Sirotkina-Diagnosing-Literary-Genius-a-Cultural-History-of-Psychiatry-in-Russia-1880-1930-Medicine-and-Culture

Slabinskii , Vladimir (2015) “Vladimir Chizh and Sigmund Freud: similarity of biographies and dissemblance of fates”. Med. psihol. Ross. 3 , 32. Cited from: http://www.mprj.ru/ archiv_global/2015_3_32/nomer06.php

Weinberg , Richard (1901) Esty. [Estonians.] Moskva: A. B. Vasilyeva i Ko.

 
Back

Current Issue: Vol. 22, Issue 2, 2018




Publishing schedule:
No. 1: 20 March
No. 2: 20 June
No. 3: 20 September
No. 4: 20 December